In a roller‑coaster of a match that had the crowd on edge until the final whistle, Sutton United salvaged a FA Cup draw against Farnham Town thanks to a 98th‑minute strike from Jayden Harris. The drama unfolded on Saturday, 11 October 2025, at the Memorial Ground, where both sides exchanged blows in a 3‑3 stalemate that forces a replay at Sutton on Tuesday.
Match Overview
The Emirates FA Cup 4th Qualifying RoundMemorial Ground promised fireworks, and it delivered. From the second minute, the game was a sprint rather than a marathon. Darryl Sanders opened the scoring for Farnham, flashing a quick strike that left the Sutton keeper, David Aziaya, stranded.
Key Moments and Goal Timeline
- 2' – Darryl Sanders (Farnham) finds the net after a slick cross from Owen Dean.
- 6' – Harry Phipps (Sutton) nods home from a Lewis Simper corner, his first goal in a Sutton shirt.
- 49' – Darryl Sanders doubles his tally, squeezing a low finish past Aziaya.
- 60' – Brandon Njoku levels for Sutton just three minutes after entering the fray.
- 61' – Owen Dean restores Farnham’s lead, capitalising on a defensive lapse.
- 90+8' – Jayden Harris drills home a low cross from Njoku, sending the tie to a replay.
Notice how quickly the momentum swung. After Farnham’s early dominance, Sutton’s resolve shone through, especially after the tactical substitution that brought Njoku off the bench. The extra‑time drama was sparked when Farnham defender Jack Dean limped off with an injury, extending stoppage beyond the originally indicated six minutes.
Player Performances
Beyond the goal‑scorers, a few names stood out. Jack Wadham and Jack Taylor provided the gritty midfield steel that allowed both sides to transition quickly. Goalkeeper Aziaya, despite the barrage, made a handful of crucial saves—including a fingertip parry on a free‑kick in the fourth minute that kept Farnham from a two‑goal lead.
For Sutton, the return of Phipps from injury paid immediate dividends. Though traditionally a defender, his positional shift to midfield gave Sutton a new aerial threat, evident in his corner‑goal. Meanwhile, Njoku proved a super‑sub, his first goal arriving within three minutes of coming on and his assist setting up Harris.
Manager Reactions and Implications
Post‑match, Chris Agutter, Sutton’s manager, praised his side’s “never‑say‑die” attitude. "We knew Farnham would be a tough nut, especially at the Memorial Ground, but the lads showed they belong in this competition," Agutter said, before adding that the replay will be a test of squad depth.
Farnham, unbeaten in fourteen league and cup games this season, now face a bittersweet moment. Their manager, whose name was not disclosed, acknowledged the disappointment but highlighted the positives: "Scoring three times against a National League side shows our quality. We’ll regroup quickly and aim to finish the replay strong."
Replay Details and What’s at Stake
The replay is scheduled for Tuesday at Sutton, giving the visitors home advantage and a chance to avoid a costly trip back to Farnham. A win for Sutton means progression to the next qualifying round and a potential clash with a Football League club—a financial windfall for a club that already benefits from cup revenue.
For Farnham, the replay is a chance to prove they can punch above their weight. A victory would mark one of the most memorable upsets in recent FA Cup history, echoing the giant‑killing stories that make the competition iconic.
Frequently Asked Questions
What will determine the winner in the replay?
The replay will be decided over 90 minutes plus any added stoppage time. If the scores are level after regulation, extra time and, if necessary, a penalty shoot‑out will follow, as per FA Cup rules.
How does the 98th‑minute goal affect Sutton United’s cup run?
By forcing a replay, Sutton stays alive in the competition. A win at home could see them advance to the next qualifying round, where a Football League opponent may await, bringing significant gate receipts and media exposure.
Who were the standout players for each side?
For Farnham, Darryl Sanders (two goals) and Owen Dean (one goal) shone. Sutton’s heroes were Jayden Harris (late equaliser) and substitute Brandon Njoku (goal and assist).
What is the historical significance of Farnham Town’s unbeaten run?
Entering the match unbeaten in fourteen league and cup outings, Farnham have been one of the most consistent non‑league sides this season. Maintaining that streak in the FA Cup would underline their potential to challenge higher‑tier teams.
When and where will the replay take place?
The replay is set for Tuesday, 13 October 2025, at Sutton’s home ground in Sutton. Kick‑off is expected at 12:30 local time.
